Legal Bases of ePrivacy – The Inteligo Media Case

The Court of Justice (First Chamber), in case C-654/23 between Inteligo Media SA and the national supervisory authority (Autoritatea Naţională de Supraveghere a Prelucrării Datelor cu Caracter Personal, “ASN”), issued a judgment concerning the interpretation of the interaction between Directive 2002/58/EC (the e-Privacy Directive) and the GDPR.

The dispute concerned the administrative fine (approximately €9,000) imposed by ASN on Inteligo Media for having sent certain customers a daily newsletter (“Personal Update”) on legislative developments, following the creation of a free user account, without obtaining their explicit consent. ASN concluded that sending the “Personal Update” informational newsletter was a purpose incompatible with that for which the data had initially been collected (performance of the contract), and therefore required specific consent.

Editorial Nature of the Communication

Inteligo Media’s arguments in support of its request to annul the fine were mainly based on the editorial rather than commercial nature of the communication: it contained editorial content, covered daily legislative changes in Romania, and was aimed at a general audience.

Alternatively, according to Inteligo Media, the processing of personal data resulting from the transmission of the newsletter would in any event have been lawful, relying on two legal bases:

  • Article 13(2) of Directive 2002/58/EC, which allows the use of electronic contact details obtained “in the context of the sale of a product or service” for the marketing of “similar products or services,” provided that the customer is given the opportunity to object (the so-called “soft opt-in”);
  • Article 6(1)(f) of the GDPR, which provides legitimate interest as a legal basis for processing by the controller.

Condividi

Post Recenti

Workshop – Come realizzare una FRIA

Beyond the Algorithm: Safeguarding the Human in the Age of Artificial Intelligence

Energy Telemarketing: Law 49/2026 Changes the Rules of the Game – 2